ESSENTIAL DIAGNOSTIC APPROACHES FOR URETHRAL STRICTURE INVESTIGATION

Urethral stricture disease, characterized by the narrowing of the urethra due to scar tissue formation, is a significant urological condition impacting millions worldwide. This fibrotic process can occur anywhere along the male or female urethra, though it is far more prevalent in males due to the urethra’s greater length and anatomical complexity. The resulting obstruction of urinary flow leads to a spectrum of debilitating symptoms and potential complications, necessitating a comprehensive understanding of its causes, clinical manifestations, diagnostic approaches, and therapeutic strategies.

Etiology of Urethral Stricture

Urethral strictures arise from a variety of causes, all leading to inflammation and subsequent fibrosis of the urethral wall and corpus spongiosum. The common underlying mechanism involves damage to the delicate urethral lining (urothelium) and the surrounding spongy tissue, triggering a fibrotic healing response that contracts and narrows the lumen.

Key Etiological Categories:

• Traumatic: This is a predominant cause, particularly for strictures in the bulbar and posterior urethra.
  • Straddle Injuries: Direct trauma to the perineum (e.g., falling on a bicycle crossbar, fence, or beam) can crush the bulbar urethra against the pubic bone, leading to spongiosal injury and ischemic necrosis, followed by fibrosis.
  • Pelvic Fractures: Severe pelvic trauma, often associated with motor vehicle accidents, can cause disruption of the posterior urethra (membranous and prostatic urethra). This often results from shearing forces at the prostatomembranous junction, leading to a complete or partial transection and subsequent stricture.
  • Iatrogenic Injury: Increasingly common in developed countries, injuries related to medical procedures account for a significant proportion of strictures.
    • Catheterization: Prolonged or traumatic urethral catheterization (especially with large-bore catheters or rough insertion) can induce pressure necrosis, erosion, and subsequent stricture formation.
    • Endoscopic Procedures: Transurethral procedures such as cystoscopy, transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP), or bladder tumor resection can cause strictures due to direct trauma, thermal injury, or ischemia.
    • Radiotherapy: Pelvic radiation therapy for prostate or bladder cancer can cause ischemic insults to the urethra, leading to diffuse and often complex strictures.
• Inflammatory/Infectious: Both acute and chronic inflammation can precipitate stricture formation.
  • Infectious Urethritis: Historically, gonococcal urethritis was a major cause of strictures. While less common now due to effective antibiotics, severe or recurrent infections (including non-gonococcal urethritis caused by Chlamydia or Mycoplasma) can still lead to extensive scarring.
  • Lichen Sclerosus (Balanitis Xerotica Obliterans – BXO): This is a chronic inflammatory skin condition of unknown etiology that primarily affects the glans penis and foreskin, but significantly, can also involve the urethra. It causes progressive fibrosis, often leading to severe, recalcitrant strictures, particularly of the meatus and fossa navicularis, which can extend proximally.
  • Complicated Urinary Tract Infections (UTIs): Severe, recurrent, or poorly treated urethral infections can contribute to inflammation and fibrosis.
• Ischemic: Prolonged pressure or vascular compromise to the urethral tissue can lead to necrosis and subsequent stricture. This mechanism often overlaps with iatrogenic causes, particularly prolonged catheterization.
• Congenital: While rare, some strictures are present from birth. These are typically located at the meatus (meatal stenosis) or in the fossa navicularis, and less commonly involve the bulbar or posterior urethra.
• Idiopathic: In some cases, despite thorough investigation, no clear cause for the stricture can be identified. These ‘idiopathic’ strictures account for a notable percentage, particularly in the bulbar urethra.

The location, length, and density of a stricture often correlate with its etiology, which guides diagnostic and management strategies. Anterior urethral strictures (penile and bulbar) are more commonly associated with trauma, infection, or iatrogenic causes, while posterior urethral strictures are almost exclusively due to pelvic fracture or prostate surgery.

Clinical Presentation

The clinical presentation of urethral stricture disease varies depending on the stricture’s location, length, caliber, and the duration of obstruction. Symptoms typically manifest gradually as the urethral lumen progressively narrows.

Common Obstructive Urinary Symptoms (Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms – LUTS):

• Decreased Force of Stream: The most common symptom, where the patient notices a weaker, slower, or less forceful urinary stream compared to before.
• Spraying or Forked Stream: Due to turbulent flow through the narrowed opening, urine may spray or split into multiple streams.
• Hesitancy: Difficulty initiating urination, requiring straining or a prolonged waiting period.
• Straining to Void: The need to exert abdominal pressure to empty the bladder.
• Dribbling/Prolonged Voiding: Urine continues to dribble after the main stream stops, and the overall time required to empty the bladder increases.
• Incomplete Bladder Emptying: A sensation that the bladder is not fully emptied, leading to frequent trips to the bathroom.
• Urinary Retention: In severe cases, the stricture can completely block urine flow, leading to acute urinary retention (painful inability to void) or chronic retention (painless, persistent residual urine).

Irritative Urinary Symptoms (Less Common as Primary Symptoms, Often Secondary):

• Frequency: Increased urination during the day.
• Nocturia: Waking up at night to urinate.
• Urgency: A sudden, compelling urge to urinate that is difficult to defer.
• These are often secondary to bladder dysfunction caused by chronic obstruction (e.g., detrusor hypertrophy, instability) or recurrent UTIs.

Associated Signs and Symptoms/Complications:

• Recurrent Urinary Tract Infections (UTIs): Incomplete bladder emptying creates a stagnant urine reservoir, predisposing to bacterial growth and recurrent infections (cystitis, pyelonephritis, epididymitis).
• Epididymitis: Inflammation of the epididymis, often a painful complication of obstruction and infection.
• Prostatitis: Inflammation of the prostate gland.
• Bladder Stones: Chronic urinary stasis and infection can lead to the formation of bladder calculi.
• Hydronephrosis and Renal Impairment: Long-standing, severe urethral obstruction can cause backpressure on the kidneys, leading to hydronephrosis (swelling of the kidneys) and, eventually, chronic kidney disease and renal failure.
• Urethral Fistulae and Abscesses: In rare, severe cases, erosion of the urethra can lead to periurethral abscesses or fistulae (abnormal connections) to the skin (urethrocutaneous fistula) or rectum (urethrorectal fistula), causing pus or urine discharge from atypical sites.
• Pain: Pain during urination (dysuria), perineal pain, or suprapubic discomfort may occur.
• Hematuria: Blood in urine, often microscopic, may be present due to irritation or infection.
• Sexual Dysfunction: Retrograde ejaculation or painful ejaculation can occur.

On Physical Examination:

• A palpable scar or induration may be felt along the penile shaft or perineum, particularly in dense strictures.
• Signs of inflammation, such as balanitis or meatal stenosis, may be visible in cases of lichen sclerosus.
• A distended bladder may be palpable suprapubically in cases of significant urinary retention.

Investigation

A systematic approach to investigation is crucial for accurate diagnosis, precise localization, and characterization of urethral strictures, which is vital for guiding treatment.

Initial Assessment:

• Detailed History: Elicit information regarding urinary symptoms, previous trauma (including iatrogenic), infections, sexual history, and any prior urethral instrumentation or surgery.
• Physical Examination: Assess the abdomen for bladder distension, and the genitalia for meatal stenosis, palpable strictures, signs of inflammation (e.g., BXO), discharge, or fistulae.
• Urinalysis and Urine Culture: To check for signs of infection (pyuria, bacteriuria) and to rule out a concurrent UTI before invasive procedures. Hematuria may also be noted.
• Blood Tests: Renal function tests (serum creatinine, BUN) should be performed, especially if there is a concern for long-standing obstruction or impaired kidney function.

Specific Diagnostic Procedures:

• Uroflowmetry: This non-invasive test objectively measures the rate of urine flow. A stricture typically presents with a reduced maximum flow rate (Qmax < 15 mL/s, or often < 10 mL/s for significant strictures) and a prolonged voiding time, often with a flattened flow curve.
• Post-Void Residual (PVR) Ultrasound: After uroflowmetry, an ultrasound scan of the bladder measures the volume of urine remaining. A PVR > 50-100 mL suggests incomplete emptying due to obstruction or bladder dysfunction.
• Retrograde Urethrogram (RUG): Considered the gold standard for diagnosing and characterizing anterior (penile and bulbar) urethral strictures. Radiopaque contrast medium is instilled retrogradely into the urethra via a catheter while X-ray images are taken. It visualizes the stricture’s length, location, caliber, and multiplicity, as well as any associated false passages or diverticula.
• Micturating Cystourethrogram (MCUG) / Voiding Cystourethrogram (VCUG): This is often performed in conjunction with RUG, particularly for posterior urethral strictures or to assess the proximal urethra and bladder neck. The bladder is filled with contrast, and images are taken during voiding to visualize the posterior urethra and assess bladder emptying. It can detect vesicoureteral reflux if present.
• Urethroscopy: Endoscopic visualization of the urethra provides direct assessment of the stricture’s lumen, appearance, and extent. It allows the physician to see the precise location, density, and associated inflammation. Urethroscopy is often combined with diagnostic imaging for comprehensive evaluation and can be therapeutic (e.g., for direct vision internal urethrotomy).
• Ultrasound Urethra (and Perineum, with or without contrast): High-frequency ultrasound can provide additional information, particularly for bulbar strictures. It can measure stricture length, assess the degree of spongiofibrosis (scar tissue thickness and depth), and identify any associated periurethral pathology (e.g., abscesses). While useful, it is often complementary to RUG, not a replacement.
• Magnetic Resonance Urethrography (MRU): An advanced imaging technique, especially valuable for complex or long strictures, particularly posterior urethral strictures resulting from pelvic trauma. MRU offers superior soft tissue contrast, providing detailed anatomical information on the urethra and surrounding structures, aiding in surgical planning.
• Cystoscopy: While not the primary diagnostic tool for strictures, a cystoscopy can be performed to evaluate the bladder for any secondary changes (e.g., trabeculation, diverticula, stones) caused by chronic obstruction, or to rule out bladder pathology.

The combination of RUG/MCUG and urethroscopy offers the most comprehensive assessment for planning definitive treatment.

Management

The management of urethral stricture aims to restore adequate urinary flow, alleviate symptoms, prevent complications, and preserve renal function. The choice of treatment depends on various factors: stricture location, length, density, etiology, patient’s age and overall health, and previous treatments.

Treatment Modalities (from least to most invasive):

• Observation:
  • Rarely indicated. Only for very mild, asymptomatic strictures that are not causing complications and are not progressing. Regular monitoring with uroflowmetry and PVR is essential.
• Urethral Dilatation:
  • Procedure: Involves passing progressively larger dilators through the stricture to stretch and widen the narrowed segment. This can be done with metal sounds, balloon dilators, or filiforms and followers.
  • Mechanism: Mechanically breaks the scar tissue.
  • Outcome: Provides temporary relief for many patients. However, the recurrence rate is very high (often >70-80%), as stretching the scar tissue tends to stimulate further fibrotic healing, leading to re-stricture.
  • Indications: Primarily for short, non-dense strictures, or as a temporizing measure. Patients often require repeated dilatations, which can lead to more problematic strictures.
  • Self-Catheterization: Some patients are taught clean intermittent self-catheterization (CISC) to maintain urethral patency after dilatation or urethrotomy, potentially extending the time to recurrence.
• Direct Vision Internal Urethrotomy (DVIU):
  • Procedure: An endoscopic procedure where a specialized instrument (urethrotome) is inserted into the urethra under direct vision. The stricture is incised (cut) longitudinally using a cold knife or laser.
  • Mechanism: Incises the scar tissue to open the lumen.
  • Outcome: Less invasive than open surgery, but similar to dilatation, success rates are modest. Recurrence rates range from 50-80% within the first year, especially for longer or denser strictures, or after multiple attempts. Success is highest for short (<1 cm), non-ischemic, bulbar strictures.
  • Indications: Often considered a first-line treatment for short, single, non-recurrent strictures of the bulbar urethra. Not recommended after 1-2 failed attempts, as subsequent DVIUs yield diminishing returns and can worsen the stricture.
• Urethroplasty (Open Surgical Repair):
  • Gold Standard: Considered the definitive and most successful treatment for most urethral strictures, offering long-term cure rates of 80-95%. It involves excising or augmenting the strictured segment.
  • Types of Urethroplasty:
    • Excision and Primary Anastomosis (EPA):
      • Procedure: For short (typically <2-3 cm), dense strictures, usually in the bulbar urethra. The entire scarred segment is excised, and the healthy urethral ends are meticulously re-joined (anastomosed).
      • Outcome: Extremely high success rates (90-95%) as it removes all the diseased tissue.
      • Advantages: Single-stage procedure, excellent long-term results.
    • Buccal Mucosal Graft (BMG) Urethroplasty:
      • Procedure: For longer strictures or those unsuitable for EPA, particularly in the penile or long bulbar urethra. A graft of tissue is harvested from the inside of the cheek (buccal mucosa) due to its ideal properties (resilience, moisture resistance, good blood supply). The graft is then used to augment (onlay) or replace the strictured portion of the urethra. Can be performed dorsally (graft placed on the top of the urethra), ventrally (on the bottom), or two-sided.
      • Outcome: Highly versatile with excellent success rates (80-90%).
      • Advantages: Can address long and complex strictures, relatively low donor site morbidity.
    • Skin Grafts/Flaps: Historically used, but generally less successful than BMG due to higher rates of contracture and hair growth within the urethra. Rarely used today for primary repair.
    • Staged Urethroplasty:
      • Procedure: Reserved for very long, complex, highly inflamed/infected, or previously failed strictures, or those associated with significant scrotal/perineal skin compromise. It involves multiple stages. In the first stage, the strictured urethra is opened, and a graft (often BMG) is laid open, creating a temporary perineal urethrostomy (new opening for urination) or hypospadias-like opening. After a healing period (several months), a second stage closes the urethral plate over the graft to reconstruct the urethra.
      • Outcome: Can provide good results for highly challenging cases but requires multiple operations.
    • Posterior Urethroplasty: Specifically for strictures caused by pelvic fractures. These are often complex, involving complete obliteration of the prostatic-membranous urethra. Repair typically involves extensive dissection, mobilization of the prostate, and spatulated anastomosis. Requires specialized expertise.
• Permanent Perineal Urethrostomy:
  • Procedure: Involves bringing the proximal urethra out to the skin in the perineum, creating a new, permanent urinary opening. The distal, diseased urethra is either removed or ligated.
  • Indications: Primarily considered for elderly or frail patients with very long, recurrent, or previously failed strictures where extensive urethroplasty is not feasible or desired. It is an irreversible procedure.
  • Outcome: Provides immediate relief of obstructive symptoms, allowing standing micturition in most cases.
• Suprapubic Catheterization:
  • Procedure: A catheter is inserted directly into the bladder through the abdominal wall, diverting urine flow.
  • Indications: Used for acute urinary retention, as a temporary measure before definitive surgery, or as a long-term solution for patients who are not candidates for or decline definitive repair.

Post-operative Care and Follow-up:

• Following urethroplasty, a urethral catheter is typically left in place for 2-4 weeks to allow for healing. A RUG is often performed before catheter removal to confirm healing and patency.
• Long-term follow-up involves regular assessment of urinary flow (uroflowmetry), PVR, and symptom evaluation. Recurrence can occur years after successful surgery, so routine monitoring is important.

Conclusion

Urethral stricture disease is a chronic and progressive condition that significantly impacts a patient’s quality of life. Understanding its diverse etiologies, recognizing the varied clinical presentations, and employing a comprehensive diagnostic algorithm are foundational to effective management. While less invasive approaches like dilatation and urethrotomy offer temporary relief, open urethroplasty remains the gold standard, providing the highest success rates and long-term durability for most patients. The choice of treatment must be individualized, considering the stricture’s characteristics and patient factors, to achieve optimal outcomes and improve urinary function.

References

1. Mundy, A. R., & Andrich, D. E. (2011). Urethral strictures. BJU International, 107(7), 1018-1030.
2. Santucci, R. A., & Eisenberg, L. (2010). Urethrotomy has a much lower success rate than urethroplasty for urethral stricture disease. Current Opinion in Urology, 20(6), 555-557.
3. Palminteri, E., Berdondini, E., Verze, P., De Nunzio, C., & Carmignani, L. (2012). The use of buccal mucosa grafts in urethroplasty. Arab Journal of Urology, 10(3), 263-268.
4. Morey, A. F., & McAninch, J. W. (1997). Reconstruction of posterior urethral disruption strictures: the traumatic stricture. World Journal of Urology, 15(3), 190-194.
5. Casey, J. T., & Vanni, A. J. (2018). Urethral Stricture Disease. Urologic Clinics of North America, 45(4), 513-529.